Words of Comfort: Recommended Readings from BLR Book Reviewers

For BLR’s 25th anniversary, we present a medley of voices and choices from past reviewers who offer a book, poem, or even a line that has helped solace and sustain them. Reviewers had license to interpret the request in any way: “maybe the book or author or poem brought you through serious illness, grief, deep sorrow, or more minor irritants that accumulate. Maybe you return to it for a mental pick-me-up when things get dicey in your life.” As expected, the responses were singularly various and moving.

As Book Review Editor and contributor of a number of reviews through BLR’s first 25 years, I have to confess that if I’d received a request like this, I’d have been intrigued but stumped. So many books/poems/lines, so much grand-scale grief and private sorrow. Plus the ceaseless irritants of life. What gives me courage to continue to practice empathy, to be attuned to the suffering in this world while confronting or alleviating my own? What makes me laugh? How many stories do I lose myself in (mysteries? thrillers? fantasies? YA series?) that have nothing directly to do with illness, just so I don’t get lost in the scary parts of this life? I recently recommended two quietly absorbing books written during those uber-scary pandemic years, to a student looking for summer reading: A Psalm for the Wild-Built and A Prayer for the Crown-Shy, Becky Chambers’ Monk and Robot series. I’m not typically wont to read sci-fi (even the cozier solarpunk genre) or any books with futuristic leanings, so maybe this is a bid for us all to read outside of what we typically turn to—just to find that delightful sense of surprise, which if the work resonates, may feel something like hope.

Kate Falvey
Associate Editor


Rachel Hadas

Late in 2004, my husband was diagnosed with dementia. Through his long decline I drew support from three different kinds of literary sources. First, were the Buddhist and Stoic writers, who were great aids to endurance, resilience, and patience: Seneca, Marcus Aurelius, Pema Chodron, Toni Bernhard all had much to offer me. I’d read them before, but they sprang into new prominence.

Second were books about dementia that I certainly had not read before. These proved to be a tremendous help as I faced the steep learning curve of a set of diseases I’d never had the need to think about. I’m so grateful to the authors of What If It’s Not Alzheimer’s? A Caregiver’s Guide to Dementia (edited by Lisa and Gary Radin); Losing Lou-Ann (Clinton A. Erb); Stolen Mind: The Slow Disappearance of Ray Doernberg (Myrna Doernberg), and many other books whose courageous authors took the time from their own caregiving to share their experiences with others.

Finally, as I’m a poet and literature teacher, I turned to poetry. Poems I thought I knew sprang into fresh relevance: Robert Frost’s “Home Burial,” Keats’s “La Belle Dame sans Merci,” Thomas Hardy’s “The Subalterns,” Cavafy’s “Walls.” All spoke eloquently to the loneliness I felt, the sense of isolation, the coming up against impossible choices. The writers may not have had dementia in mind; it didn’t matter. The human struggles they presented so eloquently were recognizable. All these readings, from all these sources, reminded me that I was not alone.

Rachel Hadas is a poet, essayist and translator whose most recent book is Pastorals (Measure Press, 2025).

Reviews in issues 18 (Beyond Forgetting: Poetry and Prose about Alzheimer’s Disease, ed. Holly J. Hughes); 33 (Diary of Our Fatal Illness by Charles Bardes; Bluewords Greening by Christine Stewart-Nunez; Malaria Poems by Camron Conaway; Looming by Jennifer Franklin); 35 (Narrative in Social Work Practice, ed. Anne Burack-Weiss and Lynn Sara Lawrence); 42 (Poisons and Anodynes by Andrea L. Fry)


Dante Di Stefano

Some days, I repeat this mantra: “through the cobbled foam-fleece,” an image that fuses pastoral woolgathering with the pavements of late nineteenth century London and renders that fusion with the precision of a Hokusai woodcut. This image from Gerard Manley Hopkins’ poem “The Wreck of the Deutschland” is the kind I could dwell in forever.

Here are two more from other Hopkins’ poems: 1) “little low heavens” for thrush eggs in a nest on the ground, and 2) “fresh-firecoal chestnut-falls” for describing a log disintegrating in a blazing hearth. Here’s another line I love, in which he condenses the oeuvres of Jane Austen and the Brontë sisters into ten syllables: “she schools the flighty pupils of her eyes.”

And here’s a phrase that, for me, embodies what it is to be a man, a father, a brother, a husband, a son, a friend, a poet: I am, even in late middle age, “a lonely began.” Gerard Manley Hopkins wreathed me with these lines and many, many more; Hopkins has been my favorite poet since I first bought a Dover Thrift Edition of God’s Grandeur and Other Poems for a dollar in the late ’90s. Almost every day of my life, whether blue-bleak embered or gashing gold-vermillion, I return to his small body of work and find a friend, a fellow traveler, a guide, a balm, a herald trumpeting the news that stays news when it comes to words and the feelings that inhabit their music: “… immortal diamond, / Is immortal diamond.”

Dante Di Stefano is a high school English teacher and poet, whose most recent book is Heartland Errata (Etruscan Press, 2026).

Reviews in issues 36 (Mosaic of the Dark, Lisa Dordal; Marvels of the Invisible, Jenny Molberg; The Book of Awe, Susan O’Dell Underwood; Another Bungalow, Maura Way) and 38 (Bully Love, Patricia Colleen Murphy and Sweet World, Maureen Seaton)


Donna Baier Stein

My recent reading of the latest novel by George Saunders, Vigil, both confirmed my high admiration for his writing and provided comfort in these often trying days of unrest and divisiveness. We all harbor our personal beliefs about what is good versus what is evil. What Saunders does in this slim but mighty book, however, is lead us up a mountain to a higher, windswept view of what those terms mean.

The antagonist, K.T. Boone, is, even on his deathbed, an unrepentant oil tycoon who has plundered the planet for personal gain. The protagonist, Jill “Doll” Blaine is charged with transporting him to his next destination, hopefully teaching him a few lessons on the way. As in Saunders’ brilliant Lincoln in the Bardo, a cast of colorful spectral characters appear to interact with both Boone and Blaine.

Vigil is much shorter and often more comical than Lincoln in the Bardo and, in my opinion, takes an exhilarating dive into exploring what makes us humans do what we do. A catchphrase appears throughout: “inevitable occurrence.”

Saunders writes, a human being is “an inevitable occurrence, upon which, therefore, it would be impossible, even ludicrous, to pass judgment.” We do what we do because of what has been done to us, he suggests, and in this perception, great compassion is born for both ourselves and others.

Donna Baier Stein was a founding poetry editor of BLR. She founded and edits Tiferet Journal, and is author of the forthcoming novel, Courtesan to the Buddha (Regal House Publishing, 2027).

Review in issue 30 (The Lioness in Winter: Writing an Old Woman’s Life, Ann Burack-Weiss)


Jack Coulehan

Some years ago, a colleague and I were walking to lunch when we encountered a homeless man panhandling on the icy sidewalk near the restaurant door. Instead of ignoring the man, my friend invited him in, handed him a menu, and told a waiter that he would pay for whatever the homeless man ordered. I complimented him on his thoughtfulness in buying the man a meal, rather than simply sticking a couple of dollars in his hat. Shortly thereafter, my colleague presented me with a copy of On Kindness, by historian Barbara Taylor and psychologist Adam Phillips, a little book I frequently turn to for inspiration and encouragement.

On Kindness begins by lamenting the suspicion and selfishness prevalent in modern society. Prosocial behavior—call it altruism, love, fellow feeling, care, or kindness—is foundational for the world’s great religions and most of its enduring philosophies. Yet, in our market-oriented culture, we remember Adam Smith’s economic theory of the “invisible hand,” while forgetting that sympathy or caring for others was, for Smith, the cornerstone of human morality. Today’s extreme individualism teaches that being kind to others may indeed be a laudable option, but it is not obligatory. We can admire wealthy executives who abandon their careers and devote the rest of their lives to helping the poor, while at the same time finding no room for small acts of caring in our daily lives. We live in an environment that encourages people to believe that kindness makes one vulnerable to manipulation or exploitation. On Kindness is a thought-provoking call to examine our behavior toward others, even homeless strangers.

Medical educators have struggled for years with choosing the best word to characterize the feelings, traits, or virtues with which physicians should approach their patients, e, g. compassion, empathy, altruism, caring. Compassion is a deeply emotional state that doesn’t fit everyday medical practice. Empathy is closer to the mark but is muddied by academic discussions of whether it’s cognitive or affective, or even can be taught at all. Altruism is hobbled by the question of how it can be possible in a world dominated by the selfish gene. And the virtue of care has lost its soul, so to speak, by being redefined as an external quantity, i.e. a sum of treatments and procedures performed. Each of these concepts has its place. However, kindness is a much simpler word to understand. Let it be the behavioral standard for all the rest: physicians ought to behave with kindness toward their patients.

Jack Coulehan is a poet, physician, and medical educator whose latest book is Leave My Soul Alone (Finishing Line Press, 2026).

Review in issue 20 (The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating, Elizabeth Tova Bailey)


Peter Bricklebank

Back when my life was alarm-bells harder, I discovered Alix Kates Shulman’s Drinking the Rain, a memoir published in 1995, that read like a long cool drink itself. The author went to live alone on a windswept nubble of Maine seashore in a shack with no plumbing, power, or—way before we were all realizing we needed to escape our devices—a telephone. She forages for lichens, tidal shellfish, wild greens, and lives, for a time, in a world I’d often thought I wanted to inhabit: close to the earth, unbothered by the madding crowd, on my own recognizance, and thus able to sink into myself beyond loneliness, into monkish insight, meditative solitude. I loved the author’s thrift, as how else did I survive back then? Her cottage was low-tech before the term even meant anything to me. And I loved the part where one day, her stairs begin to shake underneath the threatening feet of a stranger. It’s a suit from the wider, less-spiritually attuned world, in the form of a tax appraiser. I won’t ruin the scene, but the book’s appeal for me was how, try as one might, one couldn’t seem quite to escape aging or ecological disaster, or the world and its banausic business of putting everything into monetary terms.

Yet the romance of this kind of life was perhaps still salvageable. One could find a version of escape. I found myself rereading the book for several years. Eventually, I washed up in a shack of my own in upstate New York, where I annually engage the tax collector in cheery email banter, which makes paying the taxes so much salty-sweeter. The book sits on my shelf, still, like a curious pebble or worn shell. Its simple honesty, its quiet delights await any inquisitive, moody wanderer looking for a nubbin of delight.

Peter Bricklebank teaches the Workshop of Pure Critique at the Hudson Valley Writers Center.

Reviews in issues 39 (Beneath My Feet: Writers on Walking, ed. Duncan Minshull); 44 (Man of Hope and Sorrow: Stories of Refugees Trapped in Greece, Helen Benedict and Eyad Awwadawnan); 46 (Brainspotting, A.J. Lee); 48 (Intervals, Marianne Brooker)


Monique Ferrell

In 2022, I reviewed Elissa Washuta’s White Magic for BLR. The author walked her readers through a series of deeply personal and much-needed conversations about America, race, ethnicity, cultural practices and ceremony, her indigenous identity, representation, violence, family, addiction, depression, and spirituality. She did so with grace and without apology. Having just come out of Covid, the quarantine, and social unrest, it was a provocative and necessary text for our blinking eyes—now staring at the sun and our nation in a new way.

It’s been four years since my review, and Washuta’s writing has stayed with me—especially her focus on how ceremony can heal familial history and ancestral baggage and, also, her belief that we run into different versions of ourselves as we work and move through the business of living. Now, as I begin working on my next poetry collection, a work that examines the construct of time, generational anxiety and depression, egregious explorations of slavery, and violence against Black bodies within my family, I understand the need for ceremony and the power of how it cleanses. I also understand, in a new way, because of Washuta’s work, that we come into the world physically alone but, also, pushed out of the womb onto the fingertips of our ancestors.

These days, as I write my way through this difficult ancestral project, I remember Washuta’s accounts of running into many versions of her future self. They never speak but, instead, offer a type of silent acknowledgement that her body has survived and that her soul is still intact. I wonder if such a thing will happen at the end of my own deeply personal book? Who will I be on the other side of it? For now, I know myself and my ancestors in a new way, so I really do hope to see “future me.” I hope I’ll be smiling … that I’ll reach out and touch my own hand. And, I hope to be brave enough to move forward … and to speak to myself with boldness. In Lucille Clifton’s words: “Come celebrate with me that every day something has tried to kill me and has failed.”

Monique Ferrell is a poetry editor at BLR whose newest collection is bone (NYQ Books, 2026).

Reviews in issues 40 (Anodyne, Khadijah Queen) and 43 (White Magic, Elissa Washuta)


Jane Mushabac

Sometimes we crave something different. Try reading aloud Eugene Onegin, Pushkin’s novel in verse in a charmingly rhymed English translation and see if you can stop! I’m speaking of Pushkin’s 1825-1832 serialized novel which a Tennessee professor, James E. Falen, translated into American English for 1990 publication by Oxford University Press.

The book is slim. With ease, it endlessly opens on new vistas while spanning vast emotions of desire and loss. The rhyme gives a feeling of swiftness and light, of humor and conversation, until the protagonist, Onegin, eventually bottoms out on his aristocratic privilege and aimlessness. The rhythmic regularity plays with a generous variety of thoughts, observations, digressions, and lamentations while the characters desperately long for connection. As humans, we want something that makes us feel as connected to others as every line is to its happily rhymed mate. That longing at the heart of Pushkin’s novel makes it deeply moving.

What is the story? A beautiful, poetic young woman, Tatyana, stays up all night on her family’s rural estate writing a love letter to Onegin, a conceited and empty-headed aristocrat, who reads it and roundly rejects her. To follow up, out of boredom and irritation, he flirts with the woman’s sister, prompting the sister’s fiancé, the poet Lensky, to challenge Onegin to a duel.

A recent New York Times Book Review article on “beach-reads” briefly addresses an apparently popular genre of novels about “rich people misbehaving.” But those works may be sensationalized with “white-hot kebab skewers” of satire, often ending with “rock-the-town” reckonings. For the difference here, consider that Pushkin, the aristocratic author himself, knows and writes about the singular emptiness endemic to a life of privilege. In Eugene Onegin we do ultimately see the super-wealthy suffer dreadfully—but without sensationalism. Pushkin is going for something deeper than a character’s mere comeuppance or a reader’s schadenfreude. He wants the reader to experience the desolation of privilege, of thinking yourself better than everyone else because of your wealth.

For me, Pushkin speaks to today’s wealth-obsessed America in which billionaires lose sight of basic human needs. Incidentally, you might take a quick glance at Pushkin’s bio for some surprising revelations. And treat yourself to seeing Tchaikovsky’s exquisite rendition of Eugene Onegin. In the opera, you may miss the remarkable presence of the ineffable Pushkin narrator—but oh, those arias of love!

His Hundred Years, A Tale by Shalach Manot is Jane Mushabac’s novel about a peddler in Ottoman Turkey and New York.

Review in issue 37 (Sabrina and Corina: Stories, Kali Fajardo-Anstine)


Amelia Christmas Gramling

When my grandfather was dying in a nursing home in a ward called Memory Care, my father and I took turns reading aloud to him. My grandfather had always been a voracious reader, but by the end, his vision was so bad he couldn’t make out the picture on the TV. So we read him The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt. Nursing homes are non-places carefully scrubbed of any signifiers, mementos which might remind its residents that life outside old age exists. Tartt transported him to a place where the world persists. You can’t take anything with you when you leave this life, not even memory, but The Goldfinch is about the things we leave behind—the objects, the works of art—that remain and seem in some small way to remember us. My grandfather died last winter, but I still have that paperback copy of The Goldfinch, battered, cover missing, pages torn. And when I read it, I remember how he looked, impossibly small, listening to the sound of my voice.

Amelia Christmas Gramling is a writer from southern Kentucky who now lives and teaches in New York.

Reviews in issues 49 (Catch and Release, Sarah Van Arsdale; Blue Elegies, Helen Ruggieri; The Gift of Animals: Poems of Love, Loss, and Redemption, ed. Alison Hawthorne) and 50 (Mule Boy, Andrew Krivak)